The French Rise in Suicides and the Loss of Innovation

According to the Los Angeles Times, suicide is growing at a significant rate among French workers.  Many outside the country would be puzzled, since the French social welfare system is so heavily tilted toward workers.  For instance, the French employment system features a short workweek, early retirement, job-protection laws that make it almost impossible to get fired, seven weeks of holidays and vacation time a year, and even paid lunches.  An American worker – even UAW members – would be impressed.  But in spite of all the cushy benefits,
25 people have committed suicide over the last 2 years in a single company.  Other companies are reporting rising suicides, and clinics are now opening up across the country to deal with “stress related” problems in the workplace.

It’s a great example of allowing your life to be directed from the outside instead of the inside.  Governments and companies can create safety nets and provide great benefits, but they can’t instill a sense of purpose or drive to excel.  That’s why capitalism works.  For all it’s faults and it’s criticism since the Wall Street disasters, the possibility of determining your own destiny is what drives innovation, and innovation allows people to determine their own future.  Read the pages of “Fast Company” magazine and you’ll be inspired by stories of forward looking individuals and companies, using original thinking to solve problems in the social sector, business, education, and medicine.

I’m afraid in a well intentioned effort to provide for their country’s employees, France has unwittingly taken away their incentives to excel.  Innovation involves risk, and risk always holds the possibility of failure.  But without the possibility of growth, financial success, social change, and achievement, there is little to look forward to in France, or anywhere else.

Related Articles


  1. Wow, I had a friend whose sister lived in France for a few years.  She told us of the workers protesting for a 35 hour week, then as soon as they got it, they protested for a 32 hour week.  Greed and hell have this in common, they are never satisfied.

  2. Great insight Phil on the problems with socialism.  I have a friend who was a manager for company in Pennsylvania.  He wanted to give large bonuses to the employees who stimulated productivity in the company.  The union steward told him that he couldn’t do that because he didn’t want to create competition amongst the workers.  That is exactly what socialism does.  It keeps people stuck in one place like crawdads in a bucket all trying to get out but the crawdads below keep pulling him back down.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Check Also
Back to top button

Adblock Detected

Please consider supporting us by disabling your ad blocker