Online Celebrities Shook Up the Entertainment Industry in 2016

Hollywood’s Q Scores Reveal a Massive Media Shift

One of the biggest surprises of the last couple of years has been the explosive popularity of YouTube stars. As first reported in Variety Magazine in July, 2015: “YouTube stars have tightened their already impressive grip on U.S. teens since last year, demonstrating more influence than ever even when compared with mainstream household names including Taylor Swift and Johnny Depp.”  Q Scores are essentially a ranking of celebrity influence. Who has the most fans and followers? It matters in Hollywood because before you invest millions for an actor to star in a movie, you want to make sure he or she’s popularity justifies the investment.

When the shift really took hold, the Q rankings revealed:

Out of the top 20 Q scores, the TOP SIX most influential celebrities in Hollywood are YouTube stars. Then Bruno Mars and Taylor Swift followed them, then positions 9, 10, 11, and 14 were YouTube stars.

The bottom line is that of the top 20 rankings, 10 positions (mostly at or near the top) were taken by digital influencers. And traditional celebrities like Denzel Washington, Will Smith, Meryl Streep, and Johnny Depp were all listed at the bottom.

Keep in mind, most YouTube programs are produced on a shoestring budget in a spare bedroom or in their parent’s basement.  And now these types of programs are competing for the hearts and minds of the next generation – over and above traditional Hollywood. As a result, major corporate sponsors are competing for these digital programs. Earlier this year, one digital star bought a $4.5 million home here in Hollywood.

Variety goes on to say: “Teens’ emotional attachment to YouTube stars is as much as seven times greater than that toward a traditional celebrity; and YouTube stars are perceived as 17 times more engaging, and 11 times more extraordinary, than mainstream stars.”

So what does this mean for creative program producers and filmmakers?  Your excuses are over. Now it’s not up to studios, networks, or distributors to build your audience, as the evidence shows, it’s up to you.

Keep in mind that this is still the Wild West out there. Many of these programmers are creating shows that are less than 10 minutes long. There are no standards or rules – except whatever attracts viewers.

This year, stop waiting to get the attention of major studios or networks, and start filming wherever you are.

Please note: I reserve the right to delete comments that are offensive or off-topic.

  • Richard

    Phil, Thank you for bringing these rankings to our attention. I currently serve as a student pastor in TX and hear my students talk about these “tubers” all the time. It is amazing how much influence these tubers have generated over a short amount of time. As I have watched some of these videos it seems that a lot of them center around nothing other than goofiness. I don’t know what else to call it. I’m left wondering how do we compete with goofiness? How do we raise up individuals who have a more Christ centered influence on these platforms? Thank you!

    • That’s a great question Richard. It’s true on social media as well. My funny posts get a lot more traction than my serious posts – even if those serious posts are important. We need to adapt to how this generation engages with media if we’re going to be successful. I think I feel another blog post coming on! Thanks for your comment!

  • Hey Phil, are there any Christian YouTube stars (maybe not “stars” on the scale of this article) that you know of creating an interactive community like that of John Green and Hank Green’s nerdfighters community? I’m searching but I’m hard-pressed to find any Christian really connecting to this generation through YouTube (with maybe the exception of the Bible Project). My intuition tells me they must certainly exist and maybe my internet search skills are just lacking.

    • Wendy Wong

      Some known YT stars that are Christians are: Swoozie, Bethany Mota, Jack Vale, Kina Grannis, Chelsea Crokett, Kandee Johnson, Promise Phan, Charisma Starr. Hope that helps!