The Change Revolution with Phil Cooke

Dispatches from the front lines of media, faith, and culture

Being Good at One Thing Doesn't Mean We're Good at Everything

There's a disturbing trend I'm seeing among leaders in both the religious and secular worlds regarding expertise. I'm talking about people who are highly successful in one area, then seem to assume they're experts in other areas as well. Of course, sometimes it's true. I love the concept of "Renaissance people" who have multiple talents. But for most, expertise in one arena doesn't assure expertise in others. For example, because a pastor achieves numerical success in building a large church, doesn't automatically make him an expert in leadership. Some are, but most aren't. Some of these misled guys are out there writing leadership blogs that are largely hooey. In other cases, pastors who have a successful church school assume they're experts in education. On the secular side, some successful business leaders consider themselves experts in non-profit work, politics, or creativity and pontificate regularly on what's wrong in those worlds. Again, mostly hooey. The list of subjects goes on and on.

The point is, success - even great success - in one arena doesn't automatically make us an expert in other areas. I've certainly wrestled with the pull myself. Proceed carefully, because the platform you've legitimately created in one place can do great damage when those people follow you into other places where you're not so gifted. Perhaps the primary key for avoiding this kind of embarrassment is humility. When we approach everything with humility, it forces us to re-consider our gifts and the grave responsibility they bring.

Have you had this experience?

Bookmark and Share AddThis Feed Button

It's rough for leaders to admit their lack-of-giftedness. Much of it has to do with expectations: those that follow them expect them to be good at everything. It's not really a fair expectation, but it's almost always there. One of the best examples that I can think of that has embraced the fact that he's not good at everything is Andy Stanley. He's always talking about the fact that he lacks certain abilities, but he surrounds himself with people who excel in those areas. Smart move. I pray that I can find people around me that excel where I lack. It's a long list, so it requires many people!

The roof above all excellence, every skill, must be humility.

Troops hope their general is humble and asks for correction. Proud generals get their troops slaughtered, because in pride is automatic, self-destructing error.

Good generals ask for correction from all sources possible, because their love is so great for their troops, they will humble themselves to attain maturity, or near-perfection in deed. That way the troops don't die.

But then again, I could be wrong... :)

I agree with Robert. Humilty is the key. Better is a wise poor youth, than a king who will no longer be instructed.

Brilliant observation Phil - I too am amazed that some mega pastors talk and promote their leadership skills but when you see their organizations from the inside, you realize how "wheels off" and dysfunctional their own organizations are. Everything is not as it appears .

A lot can be said about a person's title as well. I think we all have run into a few creative/production services/director/media/pastor/manager/leaders.

I think this is especially true of successful business men who decide they can produce and direct a movie.

J Michael Strazynski (creator of Babylon-5) had a term for this attitude:

"I'M AN M.B.A. AND..."

From the B5 production war stories he'd tell on SF convention panels, he'd run into the attitude a LOT.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <p> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li>
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.

More information about formatting options

Your written comments on philcooke.com are the property of Phil Cooke and/or Cooke Pictures and can be published on this blog, books by Phil Cooke, or any other publication in existence now or in the future. You writing a post on this blog assigns us your permission and all rights to your comments.